Just like that, after a glorious month of non-stop football, the 2019 Women’s World Cup is over. The 4 year clock restarts itself and the countdown begins.
And I am finally able to sit down and sort through my thoughts on the tournament and my experience in France.
Best Moments
Sam Kerr celebrating her first World Cup goal by sprinting to the corner flag and punching it in a homage to Tim Cahill, another Australian football hero.
The Miracle of Montepellier, where Australia defeated Brazil 3-2. With the Matildas down 0-2 just before half-time, I was ready to give up, go to bed and wake up hoping for a miraculous comeback. But when Caitlin Foord scored just before the break to make it 1-2, I freaked out and stayed up til 2am for the whole match. It didn’t matter that I was delirious at work the next day after 3 hours of sleep, it was WONDERFUL.
Marta breaking the World Cup record for goals scored (17), beating out Miroslav Klose’s 16
That record-breaking goal however was not Marta’s finest contribution this tournament, it was her passionate speech to the next generation of female Brazilian footballers.
“There’s not going to be a Formiga forever. There’s not going to be a Marta forever. There’s not going to be a Cristiane…the women’s game depends on you to survive. So think about that. Value it more. Cry in the beginning so you can smile in the end“.
Her speech hurt though. She said it knowing this was likely the last World Cup for many veterans, such as Marta (5-time Ballon D’Or winner), Cristiane, Formiga and Barbara. The Brazilian team is and has been incredibly talented for the last decade or so, and have been failed by their federation time and again in terms of investment.
While Thailand getting smashed by the USA 13-0 wasn’t fun, I stan this tweet.
The reactions of Thailand’s coach Nuengrutai Srathongvian and general manager / benefactor Nualphan Lamsam after captain Kanjana Sungngoen scored against Sweden. A magnificent answer to the carnage of their match against USA.
Vivianne Miedema breaking the Netherlands’ record (men and women) with her 60th goal, at the age of 22 years old, and celebrating it with a roly-poly that she had promised her brother she would do.
Erin Cuthbert scoring her maiden World Cup goal and her celebration thereafter. After scoring in Scotland’s final group game against Argentina, Chelsea striker Cuthbert celebrated by kissing the back of a photo of her younger self. Her father had given her the photo before the tournament, and wrote on the back “Do it for this wee girl who had a dream and practised and practised until it came true.”
This BBC montage released before the England v USA semifinal was brilliant and heartbreaking at the same time. I watched it after the match ended, and I nearly bawled.
Viewership was amazing, with records being broken all around the world again and again, starting from the opening match to the final.
France’s opening match against Korea attracted a record 9.83 million viewers in France, peaking at 10.9 million, obliterating the previous record of 4.12 million in France for a women’s football match. That’s 44.3% of French TV sets at the time. This record was then broken in France’s next match against Norway, with 10.302 million viewers. Their subsequent Round of 16 match against Brazil then attracted 12 million viewers (18% of the French population).
Brazil also smashed records, as all matches were available on national television for free. 19.7 million in Brazil watched their country beat Jamaica, that’s almost 50% of TV viewers at the time. An average of 22.4 million viewers then tuned in for Brazil’s match against Italy. Their Round of 16 loss to France was watched by a record 35.2 million on TV (that’s double the US audience for the NBA Finals). Despite getting knocked out at the Round of 16, Brazil provided the biggest viewership numbers for the USA v Netherlands final – with almost 20 million viewers. This was 41.7% of TV sets at the time, beating out Fox’s 27% in the USA.
For the Italy v Brazil match, Italy attracted a record 7.3 million viewers (6.53 million viewers on RAI 1 accounting for 29.3% of TV sets and 0.78 million across Sky Sport).
England also saw records being broken, as matches were broadcasted on the BBC. The peak audience of 6.9 million viewers (40% of market share) for England v Cameroon beat the previous record of 6.1 million when England beat Scotland in their opening game. This record was then beat by the 7.6 million who tuned in for England’s quarterfinal against Norway. This record was then toppled by the 11.7 million who watched England’s semifinal match against the USA (50.8% share of audience). For comparison, 11.3 million watched the men’s Champions League final on BT.
Netherlands also broke records, with 1.97 million (39.2% of market share) watching the England v USA semifinal. This was a record for a women’s football match not involving the Dutch team. For the Netherlands’ semifinal against Sweden, a record 5 million viewers tuned in (78.5% of market share, almost 1/3 of the population). More amazingly, 2.46 million viewers continued to watch the post-match analysis at the late hour of 11.45pm. For the final against the USA, 5.48 million viewers watched the match (88% of market share at the time, 34.5% of TV sets). This made it the most-watched Dutch television program since the 2014 Men’s World Cup final between the Netherlands and Argentina with 9.058 million viewers.
Eventual champions USA had records of their own broken as well. Over 7 million watched USA v England on FOX, making it the most-watched match in any sport played during a work/school day in the last 5 years. The audience of 15.277 million viewers on FOX and Telemundo for the final beat the channels’ audience of 11.3 million for the 2018 Men’s World Cup.
USA fans chanting “Fuck Trump” during a live taping of a FOX News segment in a bar in Lyon after the final. Sorry Donald.
The super cute graphics released before each match that featured players from both teams. I absolutely loved them.
The USWNT’s drunken bender in the hours and days following their victory, and Ashlyn Harris’ Instastories were the star of the show, especially as she says “you’re fucking welcome for this content, bitch!” She’s right. It is rare that we see female athletes let loose, and it’s brilliant when they finally do. Regarding Megan Rapinoe declaring “I deserve this. I deserve everything”, while propping a bottle of champagne against her leg during the parade, journalist Lindsay Gibbs wrote that it was “a pointed rebuttal to everyone who has ever told women that their worth was tied directly to humility and modesty…to tone down their happiness to make others more comfortable, to turn down compliments or brush-off accolades.”
Worst Moments
Australia crashing out at the Round of 16 at the hands of Norway. I hated that they played poorly, that Alanna Kennedy got sent off and that it went to a penalty shootout. As if the penalty shootout loss to Brazil in 2016 wasn’t enough. Poor Kennedy missed the decisive penalty then, and got sent off this time. No luck. For all the hype over the Matildas being a favourite (at best) or dark horse (at worst) to win the World Cup, this 2019 campaign was a disappointment.
Ellen White’s disallowed goals. Ellen White went from being a top contender for Golden Boot to being relegated to Bronze Boot when 2 of her goals were disallowed (against USA in the semifinals, against Sweden in the bronze medal match). Her tearful interview right after the semifinal was heartbreaking and it took me a week before I could bring myself to watch it.
Anything related to VAR was almost always a tragedy. 90% of referees’ decisions were overturned by VAR, and it became frustrating in certain matches where the referee relied too heavily on VAR (i.e. England v Cameroon). In almost every case, VAR ruined the tempo of the matches with the long pauses and reviews, and fans were left confused in the stadium with no replays being shown.
Let’s talk offside. There have been several VAR decisions on the offside positioning of players, and leading therefore to the overturning of goals. And in the worst cases, the players had maybe a toe offside.
Example 1. Ellen White’s second goal against the USA in the semifinal that would have been the equalizer to make it 2-2.
Example 2. Cameroonian Ajara Nchout’s goal against England was disallowed because there Gabrielle Onguene was in an offside position in the lead-up to the goal. Arguably in the new rules introduced by FIFA (a week before the tournament started – I will get more into this later), goals stand if a player is in an offside position but have not interfered with play (see Sam Kerr’s role in the decisive and controversial Monica own goal in Brazil v Australia). In this case, Onguene was not interfering with play while in this offside position, she was walking away from the goal. Yet, goal disallowed.
The inconsistent application of the new rules was also awful. A new rule on penalties states “The goalkeeper must have at least part of one foot on/in line with the goal line when the kick is taken; cannot stand behind the line.” Goalkeepers who fail to do this will receive a yellow card, and the penalty will need to be retaken.
In an ideal world, this new law seems okay, it would stop goalkeepers from coming way off their lines when saving penalties.
However, this turned out to be one of the most controversial new laws, when combined with the oversight of VAR. It reared its ugly head in a couple of critical moments in the early stage of the tournament that affected teams in a huge way.
Nigeria v France in their final group match: to me, it made zero sense for the referee to order the penalty to be re-taken when Nigeria’s goalkeeper Chiamaka Nnadozie was adjudged to have one foot slightly off her line, when Wendie Renard’s penalty had struck the post to begin with. Renard scored on the retake to give France the 1-0 victory which nearly cost Nigeria a place in the Round of 16.
You’d have to zoom in really hard to see that the keeper’s foot is a little bit off the line
Scotland v Argentina in their final group match: this was the worst, because Scottish goalkeeper Lee Alexander’s initial save would have sent Scotland to their first ever Round of 16. The subsequent retake saw Argentina score to tie the match 3-3, and deprive both countries of a Round of 16 spot. Heartbreak for Scotland. I was not ready for Erin Cuthbert’s tears at the end of the match.
England manager Phil Neville was a blemish on this World Cup. After England’s rather ugly victory over Cameroon, he lambasted the opposition instead of admitting that his own team hadn’t played very well. Beyond suggesting that Cameroon’s coach Alain Djeumfa needed to “get his ship in order”, his following comments were awful: “I sat through 90 minutes today and felt ashamed. I’m completely and utterly ashamed of the opposition and their behaviour…I think that kind of behaviour is pretty sad. Think of all those young girls and boys watching.”
Firstly, if he thinks Cameroon’s behaviour is “shameful” for football, has he even stopped to consider what truly constitutes as shameful in football? How about the corruption in FIFA, how about the failure of federations to compensate their players (i.e. Nigeria), how about the sexual abuse suffered by the Afghanistan women’s football team at the hands of the president of their football federation?
Secondly, why should Cameroon care about the young girls and boys watching? Women’s football isn’t inspiration-porn. Zidane headbutted Materazzi, and a statue was built in France to commemorate it. Suarez bit Chiellini. Terry was a racist to Ferdinand. Drogba slapped Vidic. No one asked if these male players ruined football for little boys. Double standards.
Thirdly, Neville’s comments were patronising, arrogant, racist and reeked of colonialism. For someone who has very little managerial experience in football (men’s or women’s), who was offered the job of England manager without even asking for it, he was extremely full of himself. I’m not sure how much of his inexperience has led to his poorly worded and unnecessary comments to the media this tournament. He accused the USA team for spying on the England camp and sounded like a sore loser when he dismissed the bronze medal match as “nonsense” after losing to Sweden. For this, he was rightly criticized by former England players Eniola Aluko and Siobhan Chamberlain, as it was an insult to the England squad who proudly won the bronze medal in 2015.
As a complete aside, Sweden certainly did not treat the 3rd-4th match as a nonsense match. Look at how they celebrated at home with 30,000 fans in Gothenburg.
For further readings on Neville’s shortcomings as a manager, journalist Sophie Lawson summed it up perfectly in her criticism of Phil Neville’s tactics in her piece here.
The heat wave in Lyon was killer. Being crammed in with other sweaty commuters in the aircon-less metro and trams made me feel like I’d entered a sauna everytime I stepped in. Staying in an Airbnb without aircon also means opening the windows, but then suffering the incessant noise from the road below and not being able to sleep for hours on end. Also stuffy cafes with no aircon, fans or functioning ice-machines.
Best Goals
Lucy Bronze’s goal against Norway was spectacular. How fitting that she scores yet another belter against Norway this World Cup just as she did against them in 2015.
Cristiane’s free-kick against Jamaica in their opening match. That smirk on her face as she watched the ball’s trajectory…she knew it was going in. Such a baller.
Aurora Galli‘s goal against Jamaica taken from just outside the box.
Total Surprises
Italy! Le Azzurre announced themselves with a bang when they beat Australia 3-2 (I am still deeply upset about this result for the Matildas). They’ve been absent from the tournament for 20 years, and have rejoined the ranks, due in part to the expansion of the tournament to 24 teams, and the significant investment the Italian federation and clubs have made in their women’s programs. I absolutely did not expect them to top their group, let alone make it to the quarterfinals, but wow it was hard to root against them. The coverage and love they were getting back home was amazing.
Front page of multiple newspapers
JOY
Feeling like I was in the US at times in Lyon, particularly in the cafes in the city center. There were an estimated 20,000 Americans in Lyon, which was hosting the semifinals and final. How typically American for them to have been sure that their team would make it into the final. It was overwhelming at times and a bit of a mind-fuck to be surrounded by so many Americans while in France.
Kelley O’Hara casually coming out after the final by kissing her girlfriend in the stands. Yes she was probably concussed at the time (that head-on collision with Lieke Martens in the first half looked awful), but she knew that there were cameras everywhere, and she made a decision.
Australia bombing out so early. I had wishfully predicted Australia to make it to the final before the tournament started. Ironically, I had predicted a R16 involving Australia v Norway, but the circumstances were very different – Australia topping their group and Norway being the 3rd place team in their group. In the end, both came in 2nd in their groups. I feel so stupid now. I never got to wear my Sam Kerr jersey at the World Cup.
Megan Rapinoe v Donald Trump was a storyline I did not see coming at all. While I had expected some backlash when non-regular woso viewers who tune in to USA matches and see Rapinoe not singing the anthem, no one expected the video of her saying “I’m not going to the fucking White House” going viral. For context, this video was filmed in January, and Rapinoe herself was surprised when it was publicized before the France v USA quarterfinal. An ally for the Black Lives Matter movement, Rapinoe was the first white athlete to kneel for the anthem (in 2016) in solidarity with Colin Kaepernick, and is an activist for the LGBT+ community. To the surprise of everyone (or no one), Trump raged out on Twitter. I don’t know why he mentioned “black unemployment”. Maybe he thought Rapinoe was African-American?!
Perhaps in response to Trump’s suggestion that she should “WIN first before she TALK”, she went ahead and won the World Cup, Golden Boot and Golden Ball. *shrugs*
In various press conferences and interviews since the video went viral, Rapinoe has been using her platform and growing fame to speak eloquently and with nuance about controversial issues (i.e. equal pay, racism, homophobia, American politics etc.). Her speech at the USWNT’s victory parade in New York was brilliant. What’s more brilliant is that she was probably drunk and/or hungover while making this speech. Here is an excerpt:
“This is my charge to everyone. We have to be better. We have to love more. Hate less. We got to listen more and talk less. We got to know that this is everybody’s responsibility…It’s our responsibility to make this world a better place.”
Her recent appearance on the Late Night with Seth Meyer has fully convinced me that we all need an episode of Seth and Megan Go Day Drinking. Now.
Final Thoughts
While it’s going to be an awfully long 4 years waiting for the next World Cup, wherever it may be, there’s still plenty of women’s football to watch in the meantime.
For international tournaments, Tokyo 2020 is coming up (I hope to get tickets) and the Women’s Euros 2021 in England.
However, the most important part of driving the growth of women’s football is supporting the domestic leagues, whether it’s in terms of going to the matches or watching it when it’s on TV. Boosting match-day attendances and TV ratings is crucial to convincing the big corporations that women’s football is a product that is popular, valued and worth investing in. The players gracing the international stage are playing day-in-day-out in these domestic leagues. It’s cheap to attend their matches, and you get to see the players up close, not like in the men’s games (at least not within forking out 3 or 4 figures). When I attended WSL matches in England, I have to say, it was quite surreal seeing BBC Women’s Footballer of the Year Asisat Oshoala standing a few feet away from me. Get out to the matches people!
Whether it’s the NWSL (USA), WSL (England), Division 1 Feminine (France), Frauen Bundesliga (Germany), Damallsvenskan (Sweden), Primera Divisione (Spain), Serie A (Italy), Nadeshiko League (Japan), Chinese Women’s Super League (China)… go out there and support the players. I know I need to be better about attending the Women’s Premier League in Singapore.
I hope federations and corporate companies continue to invest in women’s football, and invest more than they are at the moment. Some good news has come out since the World Cup ended: Budweiser announced a multi-year deal to be the NWSL’s first beer sponsor and Alibaba pledged US$145 million in Chinese women’s football.
Another storyline to look for in the upcoming weeks and months is the USWNT’s lawsuit against US Soccer. As back-to-back champions, the USWNT have more leverage now than they ever had before, and are riding on the back of popular support across the country. It will be interesting to see if that will affect the legal outcome.
What a month it has been, I can’t wait for the 2023. Here’s to hoping for a solid 4 years of women’s football development meanwhile.